jalexst said:
...Untill recently I was under the impression that the dropchecker would need to reach blue again, so that when lights are off, the co2 produced by plants would'nt harm the fish. But since the DC is telling us what happened a couple of hours ago, that wouldn't be accurate to see. Is the primary reason for cutting CO2 early, simply because the plants don't need it at this time?
Hi Jack,
Yes mate, it's as simple as that. Many aquatic plants have the ability to collect and store CO2 so that later in the photoperiod they have built up enough reserves to carry on even with a drop in available CO2. In the morning though the coffers are empty and it's difficult for them to get everything running smoothly. A crude analogy would be sort of like warming your car motor up on a cold day. You need a little bit more fuel until things warm up.
At night, there is no Oxygen production, and the plants are actually competing with fish to breathe Oxygen. At the same time, both plants and animals are expelling CO2 into the water, which all adds to the residual levels of CO2 that built up during the gas injection time. By morning, Oxygen is low. To make things worse, Oxygen does not dissolve in water nearly as much as CO2 does, so at some point in the early morning you have a worse case scenario for fish. Even so, it is not a requirement for the DC to be blue, and in fact, if the DC is blue in the morning then it make it more difficult to get enough CO2 into the water in time for when the plants need it. The fish are able to adjust to the CO2 levels. As long as the concentration at night is lower than it was during the peak period, the fish will be given a break from the stress. Turning the gas off earlier allows an earlier respite for the fish while not significantly affecting the plants ability to photosynthesize in the second half of the photoperiod.
jalexst said:
Also. I have read in another post of yours that the maximum lenght of time photosynthesis occurs is preditermined by the plants. So. lets say 8 or 9 hours is the max (not sure if it is) and that is the lenght of the photoperiod. Does that mean that the CO2 demand is at its highest at "lights on" and is Steadily dropping off throughout the photoperiod? And if so what does that mean for those of us with a shorter photoperiod? (mine is 5 hours purely to save dosh.) What I mean is, am I cutting CO2 too early, 3.5 hours into the photoperiod?
Well, it may mean a lot or not that much, depending on the other things that you are doing;
Of course it means that the plants only produce food for 5 hours instead of 8-9 hours, so they won't gain weight as much as if they were producing food for 8-9 hours, but so this is not really a big deal.
It also means that the CO2 will fall to lower levels, since the gas off time will be longer. The implication here is that you need to pay more attention to get the gas concentration levels up to optimum levels by lights on as you are bringing the concentration up from a lower value than someone who has the gas on for a longer period of time. But the same rule applies here - lime green DC at lights on. This means you may require a higher injection rate, or may need to turn the gas on earlier than others to get your lime green color by lights on.
jalexst said:
At the moment I have seen the first signs of BBA and am trying to perfect the CO2 injection. What is a feasable timescale to observe changes? If I tweak the CO2 one day, can I observe the difference it has made in week 1 or 2 weeks after for example?
The thing you've got to remember about BBA is that BBA loves CO2 just as much as plants do, so you cannot just tweak CO2 and always expect to see BBA disappear. You actually have to eradicate the BBA in order to "clean the slate". If the BBA does not reappear, only then will you have known that the tweak actually worked. Sorry, but both CO2 and BBA are very complicated issues. So I would suggest that you tweak, then prune, then dose or overdose Liquid carbon until the BBA turns pink, then stop the liquid carbon and see if the BBA returns. If it returns then you need to tweak again.
jalexst said:
..and on that thought how detrimental is it if CO2 suddenly runs out? If there are a couple of days between cylinder refills, will It be a major blow to the tank, and if so what can I do in the meantime? (buy another cylinder probably)
Good Heavens, it's Mega-detrimental. Yes it's a major blow - a blow to the solar plexus, which can result in an 8-count, and which might even cause the referee to stop the fight with algae the winner by TKO. Turn all lights off immediately until you have the bottle refilled mate.
Cheers,