• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Marimo Balls

flyingfish

Member
Joined
9 Feb 2011
Messages
152
Had no idea where to put this, but anyway!

http://www.aquaticmoss.co.uk/
Just read the link above that Marimo Balls "feed on the harmful nitrates and toxins in your aquarium ensuring you have healthy water. They are great for reducing the algae content of your water by competing for the nutrients algae needs to grow."

Came to mind, could they be used in a filter as media?

Has anyone tried this?
 
That would not be possible because they need the light to grow, as any other plant :)
 
they are also that slow growing that they don't actually use up much in the way of nitrates.
 
Arrgh! Thought i was being clever, and had discovered a great idea for new media. damn!
 
Hello,
There are a few reasons why this isn't a clever idea at all:

1. Marimo Balls are a species of filamentous algae (Aegagropila linnaei) and is closely related to cladophora. So it's ironic and even laughable that someone would decide that putting cladophora in the tank can somehow cure other forms of algae...this may be the least clever idea in the history of aquatic horticulture. This is like using BBA thinking that it will prevent BGA. :thumbdown:

2. Reason #1 is only slightly less clever than reason #2 in that nitrates don't cause algae and are not harmful in the first place. Another irony of course is that this algae, and any other plant, will feed on the ammonia (which is the real toxin) but you don't need a Marimo Ball for that. Just plant any plant in the tank and it will do the same job -- and will look nicer. As a matter of fact, if you have a planted tank it is strongly advised to add nitrate to the tank, not remove it.

3. Bringing up the rear in the competition for least clever idea is the concept that any plant can effectively compete with algae. There is no competition between plants and algae because algae require hundreds or thousands of times LESS nutrients and CO2 to grow than any plant requires.

Having said all that, in an unplanted tank, any addition of submersed aquatic plant life will add value by removing toxins and by subsequently oxygenating the water as a byproduct, so from that perspective it would be a good thing. The balls don't require any aquascaping or maintenance and they certainly look better than other forms of algae which do exactly the same thing. But the balls certainly won't stop other algal forms from growing in the tank. That's an illusion. :crazy:

Cheers,
 
Back
Top