• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Double checking full EI dosing as per calc

It would be easy for admin to check the exact location of Marcel vs Maq based on IP. Marcel lives in Lysa nad Labem, Maq does not. Marcel and Maq were working together on some experiments. They were collegues. Marcel then quit the aquarium hobby, Maq does not and continued to do other experiments by himself. I think Maq is much smarter than Marcel, and he definitely is not his disciple. Marcel was the one who learned from Maq. That's just for clarification.
 
I'd like to clarify that I run most of my tanks with near zero alkalinity.
The original statement was this:
I suspect that it’s a hang over from the now debunked belief that low KH could lead to pH crashes.
It says nothing on whether pH moves are dangerous or not, it simply states that low KH does not lead to pH crashes. To that, I said that pH is indeed volatile. Nothing more.
 
Herein lies the problem. What we say on the web lives forever.

I have said this many times over the years.

Whatever I said I believed to be true at the time I said it.

And I know Tom Barr would say the same thing.
I’ve changed my view in the middle of a post 😂 … as I think through a problem.
 
Are pH controllers reliable in water with very low conductivity? (Just asking, I've never used them, I don't inject CO2.) From my experience, pH metering in low conductivity (< 25 µS/cm) is a bit tricky.
 
I buy good quality equipment and calibrate it frequently. I've been using an American Pinpoint Marine unit for many, many years now. The probes eventually do need to be replaced but I usually get about three years out of them. I calibrate once a month and rarely is it off my more than 0.03.

I also use a flow meter to keep my flow rate just slightly higher than the controller needs to keep my pH at my target. So if there were a failure it would be less of a disaster. But that has never happened.

In general I would be more worried about adverse changes in things like surface agitation and needle valve drift than a good pH controller. Even changes in plant mass and light levels can change demand for CO2. For me safety of my fish is not the only reason I use one. I also like to keep my pH drop at an optimized level regardless of other changes in the tank. It makes every other thing easier.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
@GreggZ thank you very much for the detail about your pH readings. I just read the article about tanks with low pH values (2HrAquarist) and I now think I may know what may have gone wrong way back when I started (and eventually stopped) using EI. Initially my CO2 never reached a point where it the pH was below 6.4 and I suspect that my micros may not have been used optimally as I am using CSM+B, where the Iron chelate works optimally below or around a pH of 6. Is my reading around this correct?

Additionally, I always assumed that if my drop checker was slightly yellow my plants would suffer tremendously. After reading the above article this is clearly not necessarily the case. In short, thanks for all the insight.
 
@GreggZ thank you very much for the detail about your pH readings. I just read the article about tanks with low pH values (2HrAquarist) and I now think I may know what may have gone wrong way back when I started (and eventually stopped) using EI. Initially my CO2 never reached a point where it the pH was below 6.4 and I suspect that my micros may not have been used optimally as I am using CSM+B, where the Iron chelate works optimally below or around a pH of 6. Is my reading around this correct?

Additionally, I always assumed that if my drop checker was slightly yellow my plants would suffer tremendously. After reading the above article this is clearly not necessarily the case. In short, thanks for all the insight.
Yes CSM+B uses EDTA and is better for very low pH tanks. DTPA is a better choice when pH is higher. Now was that your problem? Who knows?

A planted tank has a lot of moving parts and the first thing folks tend to blame is fertilization. Many times issues are not tied to fert dosing at all. In fact a well run tank can get by on a pretty wide range of dosing.

As to drop checkers if I used one it would be pretty much pure yellow. Remember a drop checker is nothing but a liquid pH test and liquid pH tests in general are not very accurate. Of course much depends on ones ambitions in the hobby. The more light you provide and the more difficult plants you choose dialing in CO2 becomes more important.
 
Good question. TBH I cant remember ATM 😬:oops:, I've even ask @Hanuman if he can remember
I think? Clive's suggestion of 3 ~ 4kh was once mentioned by him in regards to stability when injecting and monitoring Co2 (ph readings) I could of course be completely wrong on this.
Truth is and Clive would definitely say take no notice of kh, work with what you have, do whatever is the easiest, the plants won't care.
Also as Greggz points out, there are lots of beautiful tanks out there that run 0 ~ 1 KH.
I suspect that it’s a hang over from the now debunked belief that low KH could lead to pH crashes.
Since we are in a new era, we decided to removed the dKH values from the pre-set EI regimes in the latest update.
 
Apologies for resurrecting this thread again, but for some reason I can't get hold of the CSM+B micros anymore. I will have to order from abroad or come up with an alternative. I can get the GLA Micromix (EDTA 42%+DTPA 14%) in the US. I am reluctant as I can't see on rotalabutterfly where I would select this as my micro mixture. Any suggestions that might not require so much expense?
 
Apologies for resurrecting this thread again, but for some reason I can't get hold of the CSM+B micros anymore. I will have to order from abroad or come up with an alternative. I can get the GLA Micromix (EDTA 42%+DTPA 14%) in the US. I am reluctant as I can't see on rotalabutterfly where I would select this as my micro mixture. Any suggestions that might not require so much expense?
Just choose 7% Fe and your done done
1656609278842.png

Some of the EDTA and DTPA will be other elements also
 
Last edited:
I can get the GLA Micromix (EDTA 42%+DTPA 14%) in the US. I am reluctant as I can't see on rotalabutterfly where I would select this as my micro mixture.
It is actually in the IFC Calculator so you can make all the calculations you want there :). But looking at the backend now I noticed some slight changes in the composition compared to the website. Some of these companies like to modify their recipes for no apparent reason other than screwing with the IFC calculator 😂. GLA is a company that never answered either of my emails, sms or support question. Poor service indeed, but their product is probably just fine.
 
Back
Top