Only now I've noticed you'd mentioned PhosGuard. Removing phosphates is rather dangerous play. You see no results at first except algae disappearing. So you're happy but then you realize that your plants have ceased to grow. And then, without apparent reason, they gradually begin to die off. Those with tubers or any sort of nutrient stock hold better, longer, but in the end, they'll die, too. Phosphorus deficiency is often an invisible killer.
Does my description fit your situation?