Not been on the forums much for a long while but thought I would belatedly 'butt in' on a few additions to this thread
😉
Tonser said:
I just thought I'd resurrect his thread, as I'm thinking of converting my old luminaire to led's. Are your setups still going strong Andy ? Anything you would have done differently in retrospect ?
Also, do you have a link to the seller on ebay who you used ? The earlier links have now expired.
Yes the unit is now 15 months old and still running perfectly. No LEDs been changed at all. Very satisfied
I wouldn't change anything but I would add something. A mirrored diffuser like the grids you have on office flourescents. Why? Because the unit is above my eyeline when I sit down to watch TV and the glare is a bit annoying. These are damned bright beasties. I will get off the sofa and see if I can find one eventually
🙂
The seller I used for the LEDs and heatsinks is this one:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/20pcs-3W-Whit...emQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item35a7fd7809
zig said:
Don't know where Andy is, AWOL the last month or so, maybe he will pop back in soon and share his wisdom.
Another thing you will quickly realise is that It works out more expensive than you think, an equivelant T5 setup could be cheaper. Personally though I am just going to treat it as a project so although cost is a factor its not the overiding one for me anyway.
Alas I got pretty bored with almost everything mid last year especially the forums. Hardly use the PC these days
🙂 I'll check this thread for a few days though.
On the cost aspect yes...to DIY my unit was about £110. The T5 equivalent would be about £50 however I am using less wattage and the LEDs should last for 7 years at least whereas T5 tubes would need changing every 3 or so years. Over that time frame I will save substantially. Maybe even cost half as much total when the 7 years are up!!!!
FishBeast said:
I am new to the DIY LED thing but I have been looking into it based in luminems.
Aaargh Pet hate to the extreme. Forget Lumens. Absolutley no use to us for our needs. They tell you how bright the light looks to us!! not how much light they are outputting. Plants do not have eyes therefore they do not care about brightness however they do care about how much light there is.
As an example. To match a 250W MH for Lumens you would need approx 300+W of LEDs. However when tested the original 75W solaris LED unit showed 85% as much PAR as a 250W MH!!! Yes 30% wattage = 85% PAR. Sound extreme? The same tests showed that it was 110% PUR!!!! The 75W LED unit had higher Useable light than the 250W MH. This is why Lumens gets people off on the wrong way of thinking.
alzak said:
1-Is better to do this in one strip or two?
2-Any good shop which sell lumilux led for good price ?
3-How many high output leds i need for my 2ft tank and which one to choose
4-Where can i get some nice looking case with heatsink to hide all the leds and all cables
1-Neither!!! Forget about traditional strips like tubes. With LEDs think more of a matrix or grid pattern. The spread is key. Work out how many LEDs to use and then divide the hood into a grid with the LEDs equally spaced to gain the best spread of light.
2-See link at the top for cheap lumilux (probably copies but they are what I used)
3 - I would suggest for a medium light tank then aim for about the 1W per gallon region. For a higher light tank towards 1.5WPG. I would suggest that a good grid will need about 2 thirds wattage of a T5 setup to out perform it.
4 - I made a wooden luminaire with the same footprint as the tank. Heatsinks are sold by the same seller in the link above and a standard 'zip cable tidy is all I use. The type you use on computer cables. Poundland sell them, tesco sell them etc.
I also read in one of the posts above about lenses. When the LEDs are used for reef setups they are using 3 to 4 times the amount we would need therefore they are closer together and they focus each one down. If we try and do that then because we are spacing ours a lot further apart then you will see 'beams' of light in the water. Not desirable. Your typical lambertian die LED (half sphere in shape) will be a 120º output meaning it will emit light down and sideways. Let it do that. It spreads the light more equally. No visible beams and a good even light to your plants
🙂
AC