• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

45cm cube (hardscape only)

Johnny Ciotti

Johnny Ciotti

Member
Joined
13 Jul 2011
Messages
26
Location
Los Angeles & San Diego, CA USA
More and more often I setup a layout with every intention of planting it but feeling regret as I do. Once the hardscape is complete I feel as if I'm having a miniature funeral as the first stem is placed into the soil. Obviously this passes after a week or so as the aquarium begins to fill in, but I wonder all the while what it would be like with none of the vibrancy and movement. After watching Jeff Senske so many years ago begin to really focus on systems void of plants I though to myself, why not? So for every few layouts I take a break from plants, a time out if you will, and reset my clock. Without further rambling on the purpose I introduce my latest of layouts for your thoughts and critique.

This layout is meant to be a hardscape only composition featuring a prominent stone arrangement placed on top of driftwood. The unconventional use of smaller background stones and a large foreground "boulder" should lend to a feeling of weight and singularity despite the busy fishes.

11230198736_8516a5a965_c.jpg
 
The first thing I thought when I saw it is 'there are too many fish' .It feels very crowded. The scape is nice but I don't like the big boulder for some reason. I think I would have liked it more if there had been a big chip out of the stone so It didn't look so uniform. Maybe its just too early in the morn..:confused:
 
Each to their own I suppose. "I like that boulder, thats a nice boulder". I do agree with the fish comment I does look a bit crowded but still a very nice capture. I like Jeff's hardscape only tanks and imo this wouldn't look out of place in his gallery.
 
ldcgroomer said:
The first thing I thought when I saw it is 'there are too many fish' .It feels very crowded. The scape is nice but I don't like the big boulder for some reason. I think I would have liked it more if there had been a big chip out of the stone so It didn't look so uniform. Maybe its just too early in the morn..:confused:
Click to expand...
Most certainly I can see your point of view. I'm glad that it at least made you stop and think about what you do and don't like.


OllieNZ said:
Each to their own I suppose. "I like that boulder, thats a nice boulder". I do agree with the fish comment I does look a bit crowded but still a very nice capture. I like Jeff's hardscape only tanks and imo this wouldn't look out of place in his gallery.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the perspective. Can you be a bit more specific about the fish? What fish seems to be too plentiful? When viewing the tank in person it doesn't appear to be much at all.
 
Johnny Ciotti said:
Thanks for the perspective. Can you be a bit more specific about the fish? What fish seems to be too plentiful? When viewing the tank in person it doesn't appear to be much at all.
Click to expand...
I suppose I'm looking at the stocking with my fish keepers hat on rather than from an art perspective. Like I said I think it is a great capture and I wish my fish would behave like that for photos.
 
OllieNZ said:
I suppose I'm looking at the stocking with my fish keepers hat on rather than from an art perspective. Like I said I think it is a great capture and I wish my fish would behave like that for photos.
Click to expand...
Ah, yes. Dependent on the planed longevity of the layout I suppose I'd make different selections and amounts in regard to stocking. A long term hardscape aquarium is 30-60 days at most in all reality. My planted aquariums rarely last longer than that before before the itch for something different comes into play.

The feedback is appreciated as it keeps all things in perspective. =)

I forget to mention that with the stocking it is still less than the conventional 1" per gallon that is common here in the states.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The most distracting issue is the fish- they do not belong together, and so get in the way of the view.
 
That is a nice boulder! I like the way the mixed substrate and wood tie in with the fish colours. It almost looks like you stripped all the colours out but red/orange in Photoshop

There's a nice hard scape only tank behind the desk a Charterhouse Aquatics
 
I think it looks very striking, but I feel some of that impact might be down to the skilled photography.

We get different things out of this hobby, I totally understand the feeling that the hardscape looks great and planting can take somthing away or rather alters it. I like to see diversity in aquascaping although for me personally there would not be much interest in keeping a display aquarium without plants.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top