• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Making a New Fertilzer.

GHNelson

Global Moderator
UKAPS Team
Joined
14 Dec 2008
Messages
6,425
Location
Hemel Hempstead
Hi Crew
This is my Water Report.
NITRATE
Nitrate arises from the use of fertilizers in agriculture and may be minimised by good practices 50 mg NO3/I and appropriate controls. The standard is set well below concentrations that could be harmful.
NITRITE
Nitrite may be associated with nitrate or with the use of ammonia in water disinfection. 0.1 mg NO2/I (WTW)
The standard is set well below concentrations that could be harmful. 0.5 mg NO2/I (WSZ)
AMMONIUM May be naturally present in some waters and is not harmful. 0.5 mg NH4/I
SULPHATE .....................................................................................................250mgSO4/I

I would like to have a bash at something different regarding using the below salts.
I have various Nitrates available plus Urea.
The water is lower in Magnesium 1 to 3 ratio to Calcium.
No Phosphate information.
PH approx 7.5
SALTS
calcium nitrate
magnesium nitrate
Plus the usual
Potassium Nitrate
Potassium Sulphate
Potassium Phosphate
Magnesium Sulphate
Would be dosing into a 50 litre low tech...plus a smaller High Tec.
What do you think?
Cheers
hoggie
 
Hi Tim
Trace would be dosed as normal...every Tuesday/Thursday.
I would like to reduce the Nitrogen but increase the Magnesium.
I'm open to suggestions.
Cheers
hoggie
 
I would assume you could replace potassium nitrate with magnesium nitrate in your macro recipie and work from there I've recently tweaked my diy tpn mix from James page splitting the potassium nitrate into 3 and using potassium magnesium and calcium nitrate to make up the weight for no other reason than having the different salts :) bit early to see any difference in plant health either way though.
 
Hi hoggie, it's a good recipie IMO, I've used it for a year or so on low techs and smaller tanks, it's quite heavy on the potassium nitrate, so I figured tweaking wouldn't hurt working ok so far in my tanks for a couple of months or so, I do use ro to make it though I noticed the mix turns brown with London tap where as stays green with ro possibly due to phosphate/iron reaction which is why James adds the citric acid if I remember correctly.
 
I don't see how you are reducing the Nitrogen. Urea alone is almost 50% Nitrogen. On top of that, it decomposes into Ammonia + CO2, a Nitrogen compound that is 100 times more toxic than Nitrate could ever dream of being. Of course it undergoes NH3->NH4+ which is much less toxic at our pHs, but I don't see how being a Nitrate hater and switching to ammonium in any way resolves your desire to lower Nitrogen.

Cheers,
 
Hi Clive
I didn't actually state i would be using urea....or a Nitrate hater.
It was one of the salts available for use if needed...for any Macro solution.
My mistake for adding it to the list:(
Thanks on the information...regarding urea toxicity.
Some plants have been reported as liking lower nitrate like Rotala Macranda...that was one of my reasons for trying a different Macro approach.
Whats your thinking on this?
Or is it all hogwash?
Cheers
hoggie
 
It's hogwash mate. Sorry.

The thing is that Macandra and some other species have all these colors that people want to accentuate, so a long time ago Barr suggested to restrict Nitrogen to improve the visibility of the non-green pigments. He warned however, that if you run low on N though, then you can have N starvation, which kind of defeats the purpose. Instead of fiddling around with different mixes, just dose less KNO3. Instead of the 20ppm target as listed in the guides, just drop it to 10-15ppm addition weekly and call it good. If you can confirm that your source water is high in NO3 then you can eliminate KNO3 dosing entirely. Much easier approach...

Cheers,
 
Cheers mate. Much appreciated.

Just remember that if you lower the KNO3 significantly (like by more than 30% or so) then you might also run low on K+.
Easy to fix by just substituting with some Potassium Sulfate.

Cheers,
 
Hi all,
Decided to use tap water...and the fertilizer i made up has gone cloudy after a week. Anyone got any clues why?
Some of the elements have come out of solution, probably as something like calcium phosphate. This has happened because of the alkaline pH of the tap water.

You can try gently heating the stock solution, it may go back into solution, although it is quite likely to precipitate out again as the solution cools.

The easiest option is to acidify the stock solution with citric acid, as long as the pH is below pH7 the phosphate (PO4---) should remain in solution.

cheers Darrel
 
bZZme8O.jpg


 
Back
Top