• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Experiment: Finding optimal conditions for growing aquarium plants 2

Marcel G

Member
Joined
6 Dec 2024
Messages
50
Location
Czech Republic
Chapter 2: Growing plants with lean fertilisation in the water column

Introduction


See Chapter 1 for an introduction and more general information about this experiment.
More detailed information and further experiments can be found [if interested] on my website: golias.net/akvaristika/.

Plants

In this experiment I decided to use the following emersion plants (i.e. plants grown in a greenhouse):
  • Alternanthera reineckii 'Mini'
  • Ammannia pedicellata 'Gold' (formerly known as Nesaea sp. Gold)
  • Hygrophila corymbosa
  • Rotala wallichii & Rotala sp. 'Vietnam'
Diagram of plant placement in individual aquariums ↓

1737817755507.png

Picture of the fifth aquarium (few days old) ↓

1737817798017.png

Light

Lighting interval:
8h/day
Light intensity (PAR) in individual aquariums: 100-230 µM/m2·s (bottom to top)

Substrate

While in the first set (aquaria #1 to #4) a soil substrate was used, in the second set (aquaria #5 to #8) no substrate was used.

1st set → nutrient-rich substrate

1737817847867.png
  • I used the ADA Aquasoil Amazonia substrate (in powder version), which I soaked in tap water for two weeks before starting the experiment.
2nd set → no substrate

1737817877929.png
  • In aquariums with no substrate, I used M16 stainless steel hex nuts inserted into small size (2") hydroponic net pots to anchor (secure) the plants.
Water

Note: The recipes below were prepared using pure (demineralized/deionized) reverse osmosis water.

1737817913088.png
  • Water flow ensured by a surface skimmer (Jingye JY-350)
    • no filtration used
  • Water changes done once a week (with 50% of the water changed) with macro-nutrients replenishment
  • Micro-nutrientsadded every other day
    • Weekly amount of microelements (divided into three doses):
      • Fe/DTPA = 0.04 ppm (+ 0.02 ppm Fe/gluconate)
      • Mn/DTPA = 0.02 ppm
      • B = 0.01 ppm
      • Zn/DTPA = 0.006 ppm
      • Cu/DTPA = 0.002 ppm
      • Co/DTPA = 0.00002 ppm
      • Mo = not added
  • Carbon dioxide:
    • Extra CO₂ added to aquaria #1, #3, #5 and #7 using a simple glass diffuser, the function and parameters of which are described in more detail in a separate article
      • CO₂ concentration in these aquaria: ~11 ppm
    • No extra CO₂added to aquaria #2, #4, #6 and #8
      • CO₂ concentration in these aquaria: ~4 ppm
    • CO₂ concentration measured by Carbon Dioxide Chemical Test Kit (Hanna HI3818), which should give similar results to a professional CO₂ meter (OxyGuard) → see 2hraquarist.com.
    • 1737817939720.png
    • Hanna CO2 chemical test kit HI3818
Documentation

planting: 2024-12-18

1737817982795.png

1737818024744.png

week #1: 2024-12-21

1737818072888.png

1737818111974.png

week #2: 2024-12-28

1737818173149.png

1737818213673.png

week #3: 2025-01-04

1737818266107.png

1737818307070.png
  • Some fully grown or dying plants have been removed (so you may not see them in the following pictures).
week #4: 2025-01-10

1737818350575.png

1737818402442.png

week #5: 2025-01-18

1737818462431.png

1737818501125.png

To be continued ...
 
Documentation

Details

Week #3: 2025-01-04


Aquarium #1

1737818878308.png

Aquarium #2

1737818921936.png

Aquarium #3

1737818952310.png

Aquarium #4

1737818981431.png

Aquarium #5

1737819017754.png

Aquarium #6

1737819044099.png

Aquarium #7

1737819074642.png

Aquarium #8

1737819125207.png

To be continued ...
 
Documentation

Details

Week #4: 2025-01-10

Alternanthera reineckii 'Mini'


Aquarium #1

1737819376453.png

Aquarium #3

1737819434239.png

Aquarium #5

1737819498684.png

1737819551840.png

To be continued ...
 
Documentation

Details

Week #4: 2025-01-10

Rotala sp. 'Vietnam' (R. wallichii)

  • plants with green stems and red leaves are Rotala wallichii
  • plants with red stems and green leaves are Rotala sp. 'Vietnam'
Aquarium #2

1737819758134.png

Aquarium #4

1737819809382.png

Aquarium #5

1737819857954.png

Aquarium #6

1737819903670.png

Aquarium #8

1737819952237.png

To be continued ...
 
Documentation

Details

Week #5: 2025-01-18

Ammannia pedicellata 'Gold'


Aquarium #1

1737820175301.png

Aquarium #2

1737820210134.png

Aquarium #3

1737820237992.png

Aquarium #4

1737820267321.png

Aquarium #5

1737820295948.png

Aquarium #6


1737820322730.png

Aquarium #7

1737820349798.png

Aquarium #8

1737820373493.png

To be continued ...
 
Documentation

Details

Week #5: 2025-01-18


Aquarium #1

1737820571550.png

Aquarium #2

1737820609234.png

Aquarium #3

1737820637863.png

Aquarium #4

1737820676826.png

Aquarium #5

1737820709172.png

Aquarium #6

1737820741769.png

Aquarium #7

1737820767182.png

Aquarium #8

1737820799898.png

To be continued ...
 
Documentation

Details

Week #5: 2025-01-18

Dropchecker


Aquarium #1 → 11.0 ppm CO2

1737821059385.png

Aquarium #3 → 13.5 ppm CO2 (outlier)

1737821085945.png

Aquarium #5 → 11.5 ppm CO2

1737821105009.png

Aquarium #7 → 11.0 ppm CO2

1737821132739.png

To be continued ...
 
Results

The following data is a brief description of the visual condition of the plants in each aquarium (1 to 8). Green indicates best condition, blue indicates good condition and red indicates fair condition.

Alternanthera reineckii 'Mini'

1737821297207.png

Ammannia pedicellata 'Gold'

1737821307244.png

Hygrophila corymbosa

1737821316009.png

Rotala sp. 'Vietnam' (R. wallichii)

1737821324860.png

To be continued ...
 
Evaluation
1737821496432.png

Probable characteristics:

Alternanthera reineckii 'Mini'

The results of this plant seem ambiguous to me. Further tests are definitely needed to verify the following characteristics.
1737821554058.png

Ammannia pedicellata 'Gold'
1737821569349.png

Hygrophila corymbosa

1737821578396.png

Rotala sp. 'Vietnam'

1737821588446.png

[End of the record]
 
Back
Top