• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Alternative LED lighting

Trebor127

Member
Joined
2 Feb 2014
Messages
156
Now I have bought a new tank I now need to purchase some new lighting.

The new tank is 120cm x 45cm x 45cm. We have seen the Ecotech XR15 which we both like the look of. However, the price is somewhat very expensive by the time I have bought 2 and 2 tank mounts (assuming 2 would be enough spread). Is there anything else out there which is the same design and similar specs? I have had a look on ebay but most require hanging kits (we cannot hang from the ceiling as there are no joists above where it needs to go). We aren't keen on the rail mounts either - so it must either stretch across the tank like the luminaire or be monted on the back of the tank like the Ecotech. I have also seen the maxspect razor but not sure if the spread would be enough for a tank of this width. I have also considered the TMC tiles with controller but this would also be in the region of £500 with rails and controller.
 
You get a lot of control ability, more than you need with an Ecotech, it looks smart, I am not sure there is anything aesthetically on the same level and at a similar or better price. I had the Maxspect Razor on a 60x 45 x 45. The spread was ok, but suspending it was better. I dont think you are looking to suspend your unit? There also the Kessil Amazon suns, dimmable versions. They seem pretty good, but again depends on your aesthetics and price wise a little better if you will need at least 2x 150s.
 
You get a lot of control ability, more than you need with an Ecotech, it looks smart, I am not sure there is anything aesthetically on the same level and at a similar or better price. I had the Maxspect Razor on a 60x 45 x 45. The spread was ok, but suspending it was better. I dont think you are looking to suspend your unit? There also the Kessil Amazon suns, dimmable versions. They seem pretty good, but again depends on your aesthetics and price wise a little better if you will need at least 2x 150s.

I hadn't come across anything either. The Kessil sounds good but it's the fact it looks a bit like a desk lamp is putting off lol. I guess I will just have to get my hand in my pocket and get the XR15s. Hopefully 2 will provide enough spread?

Rob
 
The Kessils look stunning when ceiling mounted - they are very light so I doubt you need a joist (but do need those special dry-wall screws) ... the Ecotechs were much more $$ for me once I added up mounts & controllers - and I didn't like them as well in person as I'd expected - the new FW Kessil color rendition is outstanding.
If you can, get out to shops where you can handle the various lights & observe them on planted tanks.

I agree the gooseneck mount for the Kessils is absurd, it's such a contrast to the actual lamps - now they've been up for a couple months I "see" them less ... ceiling mounts were awkward for my tank location as I then got to look at (lots) draping power cords, also the controller connection is physical.

At 120 cm I think you'll need to give some thought to plant position/hardscape if you go with only 2 Kessils/Ecotech's etc - look at the PAR distributions for the various branded LED units.
I don't mean to suggest that you need a 3rd lamp (though if you wanted a Dutch scape it would certainly smooth light distribution)
 
The Kessils look stunning when ceiling mounted - they are very light so I doubt you need a joist (but do need those special dry-wall screws) ... the Ecotechs were much more $$ for me once I added up mounts & controllers - and I didn't like them as well in person as I'd expected - the new FW Kessil color rendition is outstanding.
If you can, get out to shops where you can handle the various lights & observe them on planted tanks.

I agree the gooseneck mount for the Kessils is absurd, it's such a contrast to the actual lamps - now they've been up for a couple months I "see" them less ... ceiling mounts were awkward for my tank location as I then got to look at (lots) draping power cords, also the controller connection is physical.

At 120 cm I think you'll need to give some thought to plant position/hardscape if you go with only 2 Kessils/Ecotech's etc - look at the PAR distributions for the various branded LED units.
I don't mean to suggest that you need a 3rd lamp (though if you wanted a Dutch scape it would certainly smooth light distribution)

Where i'm putting the tank it is beneath the staircase so the ceiling is sloped as well. It would be difficult to get a power cord to where I need to and don't fancy chipping into my ceilings/walls to feed the cable through...I really dont like the goose neck from pictures but maybe would in person. I saw the XR15 working and liked the design and features of it.

I have just come accross the maxspect Razor nano, maybe a couple of those would be as good as a pair of xr15s. I only thought the did the larger version of these. This option is also about £115 cheaper. Thoughts?
 
I have just come accross the maxspect Razor nano, maybe a couple of those would be as good as a pair of xr15s.?
No
Completely different sort of light intensity/penetration/distribution - which is not to say that you might not be happy with the Maxspects, I do really like their marketing, everything ready in the box, format; and they are elegant.

(note that when I looked at Ecotech vs Kessil, each lamp fixture was $100 more & mounting arm was also $100 vs $20 for the Kessil; Maxspect wasn't a great fit for my 90cm tank, to get the light distribution I wanted, Kessil was again, significantly cheaper & a better fit for my deeper tank ... "spotlight' PAR is never the issue with any of these lamps, but when you get out 30-40 cms ... of course now that my fav fish have turned out to be very CO2 sensitive, I'm running the Kessils at very low % and have completely changed "scape" plans)
 
Hmm been offered 2 tmc colour plus 1000 tiles, a marine blue strip and 8 way controller for £250. What do you reckon? My guess is that it may look a little blue and would be more at home on marine... I guess I could grow to like the mms mounting system...

What do you for cable management on the mms? It's my pet hate cables lol.

Rob
 
Last edited:
How many hours? do you trust that all is in good order (re some of the tmc tiles had sound & light issues) or is there warranty remaining?

A deal is only a deal if it's something you'd've bought anyways ... can you go look before buying? I'd not use the marine blue strip personally.
 
Good points... I'll leave it as there's no warranty. Will keep saving for the Radions lol
 
Also been offered an arcadia 1200mm OTL for a bargain price and only a few month old with receipt.

Would the spread front to back be good? Or will this be to much on a 1200mm tank?

I'm now thinking of doing a mounting bracket to open up other choices...
 
Scrub all these ideas...

Bought a couple of Ecotech Marine XR15s. Should be good :)

Rob
 
Back
Top